Jimmy Kimmel Suspension: Trump Tramples Media Freedom

Spread love

As Nexstar pulls Kimmel off the air following FCC threats, Zack Beauchamp warns America has entered a dangerous stage of democratic backsliding, echoing tactics used by modern autocrats.

By TRH Global Affairs Desk

NEW DELHI, September 19, 2025 — When late-night comedian Jimmy Kimmel cracked an offhand line about a political shooting during his monologue this week, few expected it would spiral into the most chilling free-speech controversy of Donald Trump’s presidency. Yet within 48 hours, Kimmel was suspended indefinitely by ABC, after the country’s largest broadcaster, Nexstar, pulled his show under direct pressure from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).

“Let’s be clear about what just happened,” wrote journalist Zack Beauchamp in an analysis for Yahoo News. He wrote: “Jimmy Kimmel, a prominent late-night comedian, was just taken off the airwaves because the Trump administration didn’t like what he had to say — and threatened his employer until they shut him up.”

At issue was a remark during Kimmel’s Monday monologue speculating on the political leanings of the shooter who killed conservative activist Charlie Kirk. Evidence later suggested the assailant leaned left, making Kimmel’s aside factually shaky — but far from malicious fabrication. Yet FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr seized on it, threatening to revoke licenses from stations airing Kimmel. “It’s time for them to step up and say this garbage isn’t something that serves the needs of our local communities,” Carr declared on Wednesday.

Beauchamp notes that Carr’s threat should have been “toothless,” since the FCC is legally barred from censoring broadcast speech outside of rare cases of intentional news distortion. But Carr had already opened investigations into ABC and CBS stations for alleged “anti-conservative bias,” creating a climate of fear. Nexstar — which covers 39% of the US market and is pursuing a $6.2 billion merger requiring FCC approval — quickly caved. “Continuing to give Mr. Kimmel a broadcast platform…is simply not in the public interest at the current time,” Nexstar’s broadcasting president Andrew Alford said.

Without Nexstar’s reach, Kimmel’s ratings would collapse, added the columnist. Hours later, ABC/Disney announced Kimmel’s indefinite suspension. For Trump, it marked the downfall of a critic he had repeatedly promised to silence after CBS dropped Stephen Colbert earlier this year.

According to Beauchamp, this marks “a qualitative escalation” in the Trump administration’s abuse of power. The use of regulatory threats to silence dissent, he argues, “is a favoured weapon of modern autocrats,” one perfected by Hungary’s Viktor Orbán. There, broadcast licensing was used to force independent outlets into government-aligned conglomerates.

The striking part, Beauchamp warns, is how easily America’s media giants folded. “They didn’t even try to put up a fight,” he writes. He wrote: “They apparently decided that fighting the government is costly and risky, and that risking that isn’t worth it for Jimmy Kimmel.”

The consequences go far beyond one comedian. If powerful corporations would rather sacrifice talent than risk political retribution, America’s media independence is already compromised. “This is what it looks like when a society’s elite rolls over in the face of authoritarianism,” Beauchamp concludes. “It never ends well.”

Follow The Raisina Hills on WhatsApp, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn