Helicopter Safety at Risk? Oversight Failures in Char Dham Yatra
Representative image of helicopter service in Char Dham Yatra! (Image TRH)
CAG Exposes Gaps in Char Dham Aviation Safety. It reveals loopholes, irregularities, and a complacent approach by aviation authorities.
By KUMAR V IKRAM
NEW DELHI, August 23, 2025 — A recent Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report has laid bare a series of loopholes, irregularities, and a shockingly complacent approach by aviation authorities managing helicopter operations for the Char Dham Yatra, one of India’s most revered pilgrimages. The report highlights a string of accidents in 2025, revealing systemic failures that have put countless lives at risk during sacred journey to Badrinath, Kedarnath, Gangotri, and Yamunotri.
For millions of devotees, the Char Dham Yatra is a spiritual cornerstone, yet the authorities’ negligence threatens to tarnish its sanctity. The 2025 Char Dham Yatra season was scarred by at least four helicopter accidents, underscoring the perilous conditions of flying in the Himalayan region’s rugged terrain, unpredictable weather, and high-density air traffic.
The CAG report points out that while the Ministry of Civil Aviation acknowledged these inherent risks, its response was woefully inadequate. Safety measures—like enhanced checklists, audits of operators, and flight restrictions at Kedarnath—were rolled out only after tragedies struck. This reactive approach, the report argues, falls far short of the proactive safety culture needed for such high-risk operations.
Regulatory Chaos: A “Responsibility Vacuum”
The CAG report exposes a fractured regulatory system that leaves no one clearly accountable for safety. The Uttarakhand Civil Aviation Development Authority (UCADA), a state-level body, manages the Char Dham helicopter operations, from selecting operators to scheduling flights.
Meanwhile, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), the national regulator, plays a passive role, merely issuing licenses and guidelines without direct oversight. This disjointed setup creates a dangerous “responsibility vacuum,” with UCADA—criticized for lacking trained personnel—left to handle complex aviation operations. The report slams this two-tiered system as “inherently unsafe,” warning that inconsistent national standards invite disaster.
No Training, No Safety
Perhaps the most alarming irregularity is the absence of mandatory terrain-specific training for pilots. Flying in the Himalayas demands specialized skills to navigate high-altitude conditions, sudden weather changes, and treacherous terrain.
Yet, the CAG report reveals that pilots operating in this region are not required to undergo mountain-flying training or certification. The DGCA itself flagged UCADA’s lack of competent manpower, yet no mandate exists to ensure pilots are equipped for these unique challenges. This glaring gap is not just a regulatory oversight—it’s a direct threat to passenger safety.
The Sacred Significance of Char Dham
The Char Dham Yatra holds profound spiritual importance in India, drawing millions of Hindus to the sacred shrines nestled in the Himalayas. For devotees, this pilgrimage is a path to spiritual cleansing and moksha (liberation), uniting people from all walks of life in a shared journey of faith.
Helicopters make this pilgrimage accessible to many, especially the elderly or those unable to trek the demanding routes. Ensuring the safety of these flights is not just about logistics—it’s about honouring the cultural and spiritual legacy of this cherished tradition.
The apex audit body has called for a uniform national framework to bring state-operated helicopter services under rigorous central oversight, ensuring consistent safety standards. It also demands mandatory terrain-specific training for pilots, tailored to the unique challenges of Himalayan flying. These aren’t mere suggestions—they’re critical steps to prevent further loss of life.
The Char Dham helicopter crashes are a wake-up call that cannot be ignored. The CAG report paints a grim picture of a system riddled with loopholes, where regulatory ambiguity and negligence have jeopardized pilgrims’ safety.
The Ministry of Civil Aviation and DGCA must act swiftly to close these gaps, enforce accountability, and protect the sanctity of the Char Dham Yatra. Devotees embarking on this sacred journey deserve more than reactive fixes—they deserve a system that prioritizes their safety and respects the profound significance of their pilgrimage.
(This is an opinion piece, and views expressed are those of the author only)
Follow The Raisina Hills on WhatsApp, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn
About The Author
Well written piece. One of the rare and timely interventions of CAG in recent times.